Digital Health

Visual Data | Smartphone Heart Monitors vs Traditional Heart Monitoring

Reviewed by The Clinical Committee

March 05, 2019

  • Smartphones have begun to make an impact in healthcare.

  • A new study compares smartphones and traditional heart monitors for symptomatic patients.

  • Smartphone heart monitors detected more events and helped more patients get treatment.

Abnormal Heart Beats

Feeling abnormal heart beats can be scary. All of a sudden, your heart begins thumping strangely and you feel a wave of panic. You don't know when, or even if, your heart will return to normal.

And then, the episode is over and you're left wondering what in the world just happened to you.

This is an all too common scenario for millions of Americans. Traditionally, doctors have had difficulty confirming a diagnosis based on a patient's description of an incident. Typically, patients can wear a heart monitor to try and capture data on an incident. However, these monitors are expensive and heavy.

Several new smartphone-based monitors have come onto the market promising to offer better and more convenient heart monitoring.

A study put one of these monitors to the test to see whether this is just hype or actual progress.

Results: Smartphones Outperform Traditional Monitoring

data on alivecor vs standard of care

Researchers randomly assigned 243 patients to either receive an AliveCor smartphone heart monitor or to receive the standard of care in their institution. All patients in the study had shown up to an Emergency Room with palpitations or pre-syncope.

Of the 124 patients assigned to smartphone monitoring, 11 were able to catch a serious abnormal heart rhythm.

For patients who had the standard of care, only 1 patients out of 116 were able to find a serious abnormal heart rhythm. The standard of care refers to the normal care a patient would receive today without a smartphone monitor. Often, patients are sent home and told to report back if they feel the abnormal rhythm again.

For patients in the standard of care control group who had an symptomatic heart rhythm detected, it took an average of 42.9 days to detect the rhythm compared to 9.5 days in patients with the smartphone heart monitor.

Source: Multi-centre Randomised Controlled Trial of a Smartphone-based Event Recorder Alongside Standard Care Versus Standard Care for Patients Presenting to the Emergency Department with Palpitations and Pre-syncope: The IPED (Investigation of Palpitations in the ED) study

Chart of Detection Outcomes

chart of smartphone alivecor efficacy in heart-rhythm monitoring

All of the patients in this study had reported feeling like they had an abnormal heart rhythm, but were unable to receive a diagnosis in the Emergency Room. Typically, this happens because the rhythm has stopped by the time they reach the hospital, and doctors are unable to catch it on the heart monitors in the hospital.

In the chart above, the percent of patients who received a diagnosis is plotted against months since the hospital visit. As you can see, most patients with a smart phone monitor quickly received a diagnosis for their event within two weeks.

Most patients who did not receive a smartphone heart monitor never found out what caused the event that led them to the Emergency Room.

Most Commonly Detected Conditions

most common heart conditions caught on alivcor smartphone heart monitor

Fortunately, most patients who received a diagnosis from the smartphone heart monitor had completely benign symptoms.

The most common medical conditions caught were Atrial Fibrillation, SVT, and Atrial Flutter.

Atrial fibrillation occurs the atria of the heart beat irregularly or “quiver,” causing the rest of the heart to no longer beat regularly.

SVT refers to a sudden episode of “palpitations,” rapid heart beats, or irregular heat beats.

Atrial Flutter occurs the upper chambers of the heart beat faster than normal, often caused by a “short circuit”.

Questions on #antioxidants
Can antioxidants protect your vision?Can antioxidants supercharge your brain power?Can taking antioxidants protect you against cancer?
Explore More
thumbnail for covid-depression
thumbnail for nap-heart
thumbnail for honey-cough
thumbnail for chemotherapy-social
thumbnail for sleep-disparity
thumbnail for covid-eatingdisorder
thumbnail for caffeine-pregnancy
thumbnail for eczema-bone
thumbnail for breastfeeding-diabetes
thumbnail for schizophrenia-autoimmune
thumbnail for gender-ami
thumbnail for ptsd-ovarian
thumbnail for vaccine-distrust
thumbnail for covid-heartattack
thumbnail for covid-eye
thumbnail for heat-health
thumbnail for sleepstroke-disparity
thumbnail for coffee-depression
thumbnail for cannabis-depression
thumbnail for music-surgery
thumbnail for bath-heart
thumbnail for diabetes-mental
thumbnail for coffee-filter